On Valka (and Motherhood.)

(Mostly about motherhood.)

How to Train Your Dragon 2 was funny, smart, touching, and all sorts of amazing and magical and everything an animated movie for all ages should be. But this isn’t a review, this is about the newest HBIC in town and quite possibly my new hero, Valka. Spoilery stuff ahead. valka-cloudjumper

Valka is a bad-ass dragon rider who (RIDES DRAGONS STANDING UP HOW FUCKING AWESOME IS THAT) understands dragons so well she might as well be one. She also happens to be Hiccup’s supposedly dead mother.

via theganglinggallifreyan.tumblr.com

I’ve read a lot of HOW DARE SHE ABANDON HER SON FOR ALMOST 20 YEARS hate, and how she’s just the latest of a long list of female characters who are strong, amazing, and interesting but useless. And maybe that’s true (Not really.), but she’s relevant to me.

I’m very vocal about my non-interest in becoming a mother. Or rather, I’ve had to be vocal because once I got into my late twenties, the stream of when-are-you-settling-down-and-giving-your-mother-a-grandchild questions never just seem to end. When I was in grade school, I thought I would change my mind eventually as I got older but I’m almost 30 and I still have no maternal instinct whatsoever.

Maybe someday I’ll get that urge when I’m menopausing and my ovaries are making a last-ditch attempt to pro-create, and maybe I won’t.

And that’s okay.

I think a lot of my female friends and relatives take it against them, but my saying no isn’t a critique of women everywhere who are/ plan to be moms. I see motherhood as a choice, and it’s a choice I don’t see myself making anytime soon, if ever. Going back to Valka, here is a woman who chose to live among dragons to save them instead of going back to an infant son and a husband she loves. I’m not saying abandonment is right, I’m just saying I appreciate that for the first time, an animated film acknowledges that not all women are innately maternal. A great article on the Daily Dot has articulated this much more eloquently than I ever will:

In absolutely every other Hollywood version of the HTTYD 2 narrative, Hiccup’s discovery of his mother’s two-decade-long absence would have resulted in an explicit shaming of her choices and a prolonged “how could you abandon me?” confrontation that would probably have ended with her breaking down in tears and Hiccup’s eventual acceptance and forgiveness of her inexplicable absence all this time. Instead, Hiccup instantly and immediately recognized that his mom’s choices were her own choices, and that they were obviously valuable and important. At no point did the narrative shame Valka for rejecting her role as a mother and a housewife.
Why ‘How to Train Your Dragon 2’ is a radical feminist triumph“, By Aja Romano

So thanks, Dreamworks.

via daciio.tumblr.com

This post was brought to you by post-recent birthday existentialism.

Published by


Grumpy Pants; Occasional Clever Clogs.・ MNL 🇵🇭 x KTM 🇳🇵 ・ ♠️⚪️💜

2 thoughts on “On Valka (and Motherhood.)”

  1. I imagine an alternate version where Valka’s the dad who left Hiccup because he felt it was his mission to save and study dragons. That there is no place in Berk (or the world) for him and since there is no sanctuary of peace anywhere close, he’d have to create one. Yet every day he thinks about Hiccup with loads of regret. Alas fatherhood’s just not his thing. And what if Hiccup doesn’t accept/recognize him? Sigh no going back now; the dragons are his people. Eventually Hiccup and dude-Valka reunite. What a cool dad he is, too. Cue father-son bonding funtime montage. End movie with a big sacrificial/redemptive move where he almost dies and “I’m never leaving you again I promise.”

    Dude-Valka seems easier to forgive for some reason. Aladdin’s King of Thieves dad didn’t get as much hate, if any. We are so used to that being ok.

    Kudos to Dreamworks for giving us a perfect example of a non-maternal woman who isn’t evil.

Leave a Reply to Jooley Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s